Off The Tracks

Off The Tracks
  • Blog
    • Interviews
    • Miscellany
    • Special Guests
    • Reviews
  • Podcasts
  • The Vinyl Countdown
  • Back Catalogue
  • About
    • About
    • About the banner image
    • On Song
    • Advertise
February 26, 2017 by Simon Sweetman

The Voice Is Gone, Man: When Singers Can No Longer Sing

12389240There’s a demo version of Bob Dylan singing Like A Rolling Stone, just Bob at the piano, it’s just over a minute long. I like it more than the original. It’s part of the original Bootleg series and that’s easily one of the most important collections of music I ever heard in my life. It opened doors, and worlds – so many songs swirling past my ears, so many new (and old) things to discover as a result of that; including a lifelong membership to the Dylan fan club.

His demo version of Rolling Stone falls away and he announces, “my voice is gone, man”. And people that do not understand what Dylan’s voice is and what it does will be lining up for the cheap-shot joke. And fair enough. Get ’em while you can. But you’re wrong.

Even when Dylan’s voice was – by his own standards – gone it still sounds pretty good to me.

Remembering the Meat Loaf show from just a few years back – obvious example. He would sign his retirement with that tour and the appearances in Australia hawking a bit of sport. Well, he hasn’t quite retired – but he should have.

And here was a guy who could really sing.

But that voice is in tatters now – as happens when you are out there working it for so long, so often.

I was never the biggest Meat Loaf fan but I knew his music – had a couple of entertaining phone calls with him, one not really an interview and one so much more than just an interview…but that concert really was the worst. An embarrassment. If I’d have paid with anything other than my time I would have wanted my money back – because it didn’t do what it said on the ticket: Meat Loaf was advertised as being there to sing. And he could not.

I was also revisiting the time Blondie and The Pretenders played a winery gig a few years back. Good show, this – even though Deborah Harry could no longer sing. She seemed to get by, because she was trying and because the band sounded great and the energy was right and you realised that it was about more than just her, it was about a fantastic catalogue of songs (even though that catalogue of songs and the band’s worth were all built around Harry as the selling point).

The Blondie gig was better than the Meat Loaf gig – to compare two shows where the singers were struggling. But that’s because you can get more from a Blondie show than just Debbie Harry; the songs, the other band members…also The Pretenders were great (perhaps a little underappreciated on that day by that crowd).

But those are two most obvious examples – as well as the car crash that was K-Ci & JoJo – where the singers were out of luck; their voices gone, man.

Have you ever been to a show where the lead singer was working way beyond borrowed time, should have thrown in the towel, couldn’t actually deliver? It’s a rather heart-breaking thing if you’re a fan of the band or artist. And it’s just insulting if you’ve paid a heap of money.

Posted in Blog, Miscellany and tagged with Blondie, Bob Dylan, Concerts, Debbie Harry, Gone, Live, Man: When Singers Can No Longer Sing, Meat Loaf, Singing, The Pretenders, The Voice Is Gone, The Voice is Gone Man, voice, When Singes Can No Longer Sing. RSS 2.0 feed.
« The Ghost of Electricity: War Stories by Jon McLeary # 151 Good Sunday
Emily Writes: Rants In The Dark »

2 Responses to The Voice Is Gone, Man: When Singers Can No Longer Sing

  1. Simon Grigg says:
    March 1, 2017 at 3:44 am

    Sadly, Simon, Paul McCartney mostly can’t do the notes anymore. His performance at the London Olympics was abysmal.

  2. Oingo says:
    June 24, 2017 at 4:38 pm

    Christine Mcvie, Donald Fagan, come to mind

Popular

  • Janna Lapidus Leblanc: Four Years In Pictures
  • The Sad Story of Bob Welch: Fleetwood Mac’s Most Undervalued Member
  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 8 – Mark Knopfler
  • John Patitucci / Vinnie Colaiuta / Bill Cunliffe: TRIO
  • Sweetman Podcast # 247: Talia Marshall
  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 11 – Lindsey Buckingham
  • Poem: “It Was Like Watching Myself Die”
  • Substack: “Sounds Good!”
  • R.I.P. Lawrence Ferlinghetti
  • Revisiting Live at Knebworth (1990)

Archives

Tags

Album Review Auckland Book Book Review Chat Compilation DJ DVD DVD Review EP Film Film Review Gig Gig Review Guest Blog Guitar Interview Jazz Jon Mcleary Live Live Gig LP Movie Music NZ Podcast Poem Record Records Simon Sweetman Soundtrack Spines Spotify Stub Stubs Sweetman Podcast The Ghost of Electricity The Spines The Vinyl Countdown Vinyl Wellington Wgtn Writing You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron [OST]

Categories

  • Back Catalogue
  • Blog
  • Interviews
  • Miscellany
  • Mixtapes
  • Playlists
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews
  • Scene Of The Day
  • Special Guests
  • The Vinyl Countdown

Off The Tracks is the home of Sweetman Podcast, a weekly interview/chat-based pod. It's also home to my reviews across film, TV, music and books and some creative writing as well.

Off The Tracks aims to provide quality reviews and essays, regular blog updates about the shows, albums, books and movies you should be experiencing.

It's a passion project. Your support will help to keep Off The Tracks online.

All content © 2021 by Off The Tracks. WordPress Themes by Graph Paper Press