Off The Tracks

Off The Tracks
  • Blog
    • Interviews
    • Miscellany
    • Special Guests
    • Reviews
  • Podcasts
  • The Vinyl Countdown
  • Back Catalogue
  • About
    • About
    • About the banner image
    • On Song
    • Advertise
March 12, 2018 by Simon Sweetman

NZ Festival Writers & Readers: Francis Spufford & Elizabeth Knox Talk About God

nzf-stacked-blackFrancis Spufford & Elizabeth Knox Talk About God

Circa One, Circa Theatre

Saturday, March 10

This Writers & Readers session featured a conversation about God between long-time correspondents Francis Spufford (UK) and Elizabeth Knox (NZ).

It was, if you’ll pardon the pun, a spirited conversation. It was lively, funny and often irritating. For a start, Knox offers an easy lay-up assist to Spufford allowing him to slam dunk Richard Dawkins for no real reason other than to pick the biggest – and best? – opposition and attempt to lay him to waste. The problems with this are many, just as it’s suddenly problematic to seem like you’re at the defence of Dawkins. But the burden of proof is not with him and however clumsily he might have argued some of his points his frustrations are clear. Mocking them, or him, doesn’t accurately dispute his claims.

It was a shame because Spufford was a terrific orator, a lovely presence – thoughtful and deeply engaged with the subject. When Dawkins was mentioned near the end in a question, one Spufford couldn’t really answer, he chose to simply go ad hominem on Dawkins once again.

It’s not to suggest that this is the problem with religion – but it was one of the obvious problems during this talk.

Knox was difficult to grasp here. She seemed to want to put across a belief – whilst hiding in the back room. Spufford, a church-goer, married to a minister, had his stripes there clear for all to see. I’m not sure which was the best approach. But it was, in parts, a terrific conversation – not least because it was unscripted; feeling like a taping for a podcast that the audience had chanced upon. I mean this, of course, in the best possible way.

As I get older I’m far more lenient – my belief is simply one of whatever gets you through the day. The Dawkins brigade and other “hardcore” atheists are as frustrating as any born-again zealot. If you’re doing no harm to me – if a belief guides you in some way and is not a misguided, harmful, hateful propaganda then good on you. Good for you. And god for you. But there were moments in this talk where, Spufford in particular, seemed to talk down to anyone that didn’t believe, was certain his faith was something superior.

It felt like there were plenty of believes in the audience – I went along not as sceptic, as such, but certainly not as what you’d deem any sort of believe. Someone merely curious to hear an interesting conversation, to learn something. I’m not entirely sure I did learn anything, but that’s not (really) the fault of the talented, passionate and talented speakers.

I left in some bafflement though. Something didn’t quite stick, didn’t sit. I enjoyed that though.
Francis_Spufford_and_Elizabet.2e16d0ba.fill-600x315-c100_UkLgs3zYou can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron

Posted in Blog, Reviews and tagged with 2018), Author Talk, Christianity, Circa, Circa One, Circa Studio, Circa Theatre, Discussion, England, Francis Spufford & Elizabeth Knox, Francis Spufford & Elizabeth Knox Talk About God, God, March 10, New Zealand, Non-FIction, Novel, Novelist, NZ, NZ Festival, NZ Festival Writers & Readers: Francis Spufford & Elizabeth Knox Talk About God, Readers, Religion, Richard Dawkins, Saturday, Talk, Talk About God, UK, Wellington, Writers, Writers & Readers, You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron. RSS 2.0 feed.
« The Vinyl Countdown # 425
PP Arnold to Play One NZ Show: Akld May 20, 2018 »

Popular

  • Charlotte Grimshaw: The Mirror Book
  • Janna Lapidus Leblanc: Four Years In Pictures
  • The Sad Story of Bob Welch: Fleetwood Mac’s Most Undervalued Member
  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 8 – Mark Knopfler
  • Sweetman Podcast # 253: Margot Pierard
  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 11 – Lindsey Buckingham
  • Bob Dylan: The Best of The Bootleg Series
  • Merry Clayton: Beautiful Scars
  • Revisiting Live at Knebworth (1990)
  • Fatman: DVD

Archives

Tags

Album Review Auckland Book Book Review Chat Compilation DJ DVD DVD Review EP Film Film Review Gig Gig Review Guest Blog Guitar Interview Jazz Jon Mcleary Live Live Gig LP Movie Music NZ Podcast Poem Record Records Simon Sweetman Soundtrack Spines Spotify Stub Stubs Sweetman Podcast The Ghost of Electricity The Spines The Vinyl Countdown Vinyl Wellington Wgtn Writing You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron [OST]

Categories

  • Back Catalogue
  • Blog
  • Interviews
  • Miscellany
  • Mixtapes
  • Playlists
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews
  • Scene Of The Day
  • Special Guests
  • The Vinyl Countdown

Off The Tracks is the home of Sweetman Podcast, a weekly interview/chat-based pod. It's also home to my reviews across film, TV, music and books and some creative writing as well.

Off The Tracks aims to provide quality reviews and essays, regular blog updates about the shows, albums, books and movies you should be experiencing.

It's a passion project. Your support will help to keep Off The Tracks online.

All content © 2021 by Off The Tracks. WordPress Themes by Graph Paper Press