Off The Tracks

Off The Tracks
  • Blog
    • Interviews
    • Miscellany
    • Special Guests
    • Reviews
  • Podcasts
  • The Vinyl Countdown
  • Back Catalogue
  • About
    • About
    • About the banner image
    • On Song
November 3, 2019 by Simon Sweetman

Dylan Jones: The Wichita Lineman – Searching In The Sun For The World’s Greatest Unfinished Song

The Wichita Lineman: Searching In The Sun For The World’s Greatest Unfinished Song

Dylan Jones

Faber & Faber Social

It’s anyone’s guess what the “greatest” song of all time is – but a clever choice might be Wichita Lineman as recorded by Glen Campbell and written by Jimmy Webb. You could certainly do a lot worse.

You could do a lot worse than having Dylan Jones as your guide too – he loves Wichita Lineman and does his best to get to the bottom of it. The problem, I guess, is that he resolves, rather quickly, as many of us have – listening to it over the years and in many versions – is that the magic is really in the lines, “And I need her more than want her, and I want her for all time” – that couplet is the magic. He knows it. He knows that we know it; that Webb and Campbell know it too – and so that’s what allows him to take us on a bigger journey…

What a journey this song is.

Jones basically takes us through bits of Campbell’s biography – the Wrecking Crew, the Beach Boys and others – and then Webb’s early career, songwriter to Campbell and many more…

The problem with this book is that it answers the question almost straight away. It tells us that the song is mercurial, it touches on all the aspects – assessing writer and performer – and then it has to do that over and again.

We get lots of great info about Webb. Plenty about Campbell.

And then we get some good stuff about the setting of the song and the aim of the song.

It’s beautiful actually. It’s a masterful approach. Jones even touches on cover-versions, as well as touching on the work that Campbell and Webb had to do outside and away from this song. The problem, ultimately, is that it’s a hard-sell making this a 300-page book.

Other single volumes about songs that I love – and that anybody must know/love – include Greil Marcus on Dylan’s Like A Rolling Stone and David Maglick’s beautiful book about Billie Holiday’s Strange Fruit and there are more, but these two show that you don’t need so many pages to say, and say again, that the song and the artist and the writer is magnificent.

And I think, ultimately, that Jones spends a bit much time re-hashing the biographies. A better use of time might have been getting the rights to the Webb/Campbell stories. But that’s maybe being a bit grumpy – because the writing here is lovely, the song is the best and the way he sells it, and shows it, is spectacular. Jones knows the history. And he sells it and shows it well – there’s a bit of repetition. But that’s ultimately collateral damage. If you love songs and music and music-history then you will find more than enough here that you’ll love. The way this story unfold is subtly magnificent; as is the way the song unfolds. You’ll love this book if you’re the right candidate for it – and you’ll listen to it over and again – and then find so many great cover versions including Dave Dobbyn singing it for an ad!
You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron

Posted in Blog, Reviews and tagged with Author, Book, Book Review, Dylan Jones, Dylan Jones: The Wichita Lineman, Faber & Faber Social, Glen Campbell, History, Jimmy Webb, Music, Music History, Searching In The Sun For The World’s Greatest Unfinished Song, Song, The Wichita Lineman: Searching In The Sun For The World’s Greatest Unfinished Song, Writer, Writing, You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron. RSS 2.0 feed.
« Aoife O’Donovan: In The Magic Hour Solo Sessions (ep)
Poem: Capitalism Creeps »

Popular

  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 8 – Mark Knopfler
  • Janna Lapidus Leblanc: Four Years In Pictures
  • The Sad Story of Bob Welch: Fleetwood Mac’s Most Undervalued Member
  • Sweetman Podcast: Episode 73 – Janna Lapidus Leblanc
  • The Best Guitarist in The World: # 11 – Lindsey Buckingham
  • Neil Peart Was The World’s Most Overrated Drummer
  • David Bowie’s Most Underrated Album: 1. Outside
  • Time Casts Its Spell: When Silver Springs Became The Secret Weapon It Had Always Threatened To Be
  • A Very Benign And In-Character Midlife Crisis: I’m Back Buying CDs
  • Poem: Too Much Tumult

Archives

Tags

Album Review Auckland Blog Book Book Review Chat Compilation DJ Drums DVD DVD Review EP Film Film Review Gig Gig Review Guest Blog Guitar Interview Jazz Live Live Gig LP Movie Music NZ Podcast Poem Poetry Record Records Simon Sweetman Soundtrack Spotify Stub Stubs Sweetman Podcast The Vinyl Countdown Vinyl Want more? Check out my Substack You can also support Off The Tracks via PressPatron Wellington Wgtn Writing You can support Off The Tracks via PressPatron [OST]

Categories

  • Back Catalogue
  • Blog
  • Interviews
  • Miscellany
  • Mixtapes
  • Playlists
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews
  • Scene Of The Day
  • Special Guests
  • The Vinyl Countdown

Off The Tracks is the home of Sweetman Podcast, a weekly interview/chat-based pod. It's also home to my reviews across film, TV, music and books and some creative writing as well.

Off The Tracks aims to provide quality reviews and essays, regular blog updates about the shows, albums, books and movies you should be experiencing.

It's a passion project. Your support will help to keep Off The Tracks online.

All content © 2022 by Off The Tracks. WordPress Themes by Graph Paper Press